An open mind and flexibility are required if the border with China is to be settled, felt Maj Gen Ashok Singh (Retd) while presenting the talk ‘The Border, the War and Our Collective Ignorance’ at the India International Centre on Wednesday.
Maj Gen Singh, a recipient of the Yudh Seva Medal and Sena Medal for gallantry emphasised that a certain level of give and take is essential to reach an agreement
“It is a very complex situation as it is engrained in the mindset of Indians that the border is sacred and integral territory of the country which cannot be violated. For any solution to come through at some stage in the future we need to get out of this mentality. I am willing to accept that a border settlement will require a give and take.”
He felt that Zhou Enlai’s 1960 border solution should have been seriously considered by the Indian government of the time “During his 1960 India visit, Zhou Enlai was not even accorded the protocol that is befitting of a Prime Minister of a major nation like China, he shuffled from one minister’s house to another, despite that when he was departing from Palam airport he made the same offer.
He stated that India and China have a border difference, India China have a Line of Actual control, let us control the area of what is under each, which means Tawang and NEFA(North East Frontier Agency) remains with India while Aksai Chin remains under China.”
He was of the opinion that China’s basic motive to wage a war against India in 1962 was to capture area for using it as a bargaining chip”war is a subset of politics, they waged a war to capture area, then they pulled back and offered negotiations. After capturing Tawang, the Chinese offered a ceasefire and negotiations to India. Chinese premier Zhou Enlai said that the LAC will be defined based on the November 7, 1959 proposal, we did not listen, things escalated and the war progressed up to November 20 when the unilateral ceasefire was declared.”
He reiterated that China has been reasonable in its border settlement with its neighbors and India should also settle the border as per negotiations “Myanmar renegotiated the Mc Mohan line with China and got a good bargain, Nepal renegotiated and got a good bargain, Pakistan got a good bargain by negotiating as well.
Discussions have taken place between the special representatives of the two countries who accepted that there is a dispute, they are going to follow some principles in order to settle the dispute, they are going to look into the historical evidence that each side is going to bring, they are going to look into the reasonableness of each other’s claims, they are going to look into the settlement of people, settled populations are not required to be displaced.”
He reasoned that the US President at that time of the India- China war- John F. Kennedy was in no position to intervene as he was preoccupied with the Cuban missile crisis.
